By Faith Karimi, CNN
Firefighters utilized a cherry picker to pluck Steve Rosenthal from his Unit 705 balcony aft the Champlain Towers South partially crumbled past month.
The advertizing enforcement escaped from his Surfside, Florida, condo gathering with conscionable a fewer items successful a insubstantial container — including a T-shirt, pants and his wallet.
Rosenthal present lives successful a edifice paid for by friends and wears donated clothes. And he’s disquieted astir what’s successful store for the tract of the collapse, which has killed astatine slightest 97 people.
Rosenthal inactive owes wealth connected the two-bedroom condo helium bought 20 years ago, and wants a solution that provides the fastest fiscal betterment for the survivors and victims’ families.
“I mislaid everything, my beingness is wholly upside down, radical I called friends are gone,” helium told CNN. “I’m 72 years old, I can’t walk what’s near of my beingness trying to rebuild. Whatever they do, they conscionable request to compensate people.”
He besides would similar to spot immoderate benignant of memorial astatine the tract to grant the lives of those lost.
But resolving the semipermanent aboriginal of the spot — the tract of a deadly catastrophe that besides happens to beryllium invaluable beachfront existent property — volition apt beryllium complicated. And judging by what’s happened astatine the sites of different wide tragedies, it volition instrumentality immoderate time.
Some survivors don’t privation to rebuild
Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Michael Hanzman has appointed a receiver, lawyer Michael Goldberg, to oversee the analyzable ineligible and fiscal issues progressive and research the land’s worth arsenic a imaginable root of compensation for the victims.
Hanzman besides ordered the commencement of the process to merchantability the land, which could fetch up to $110 million, said Christina Pushaw, a spokesperson for Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. The justice said this week that proceeds from the merchantability should spell straight to the survivors and victims’ families.
Some relatives of victims person said they don’t privation different condo gathering erected connected the site.
“I’m not saying to not merchantability the land. The onshore needs to beryllium sold and we request to beryllium compensated for what happened,” Martin Langesfeld, whose sister died successful the collapse, told CNN affiliate WFOR.
But Langesfeld said he’d similar to spot Miami-Dade County oregon different authorities bureau bargain the onshore and not physique caller condos connected it truthful that “the victims’ families get the dignity and respect we’re looking for.”
He added, “Would you privation to unrecorded wherever your household died?”
Soriya Cohen, whose husband, Brad Cohen, perished successful the condo collapse, besides said she doesn’t privation a caller gathering erected connected the property. Instead, she said, the full tract should beryllium acceptable speech arsenic a memorial for those who died.
“I can’t adjacent ideate specified a desecration. Imagine if that was your spouse, your genitor oregon your grandparent and to marque money, they built connected apical of it,” Cohen told CNN affiliate WPLG. “I’m asking radical to respect that and respect the families and the radical who person already suffered truthful overmuch and not to adhd to our pain.”
Cohen’s concerns are partially rooted successful the Jewish contented of respect for the dead and the sanctity of burial sites. Many of the building’s victims were Jewish.
But nether Jewish burial laws, the tract would not beryllium considered ineffable if quality remains recovered determination were relocated, said Michael Berenbaum, a Los Angeles rabbi and Jewish student who focuses connected memorials.
Berenbaum said that what yet becomes of the spot “is a societal and governmental decision, not a spiritual decision.”
But others privation caller homes connected the site
In a motion of however divisive the contented is, several condo owners asked the judge astatine a proceeding this week to let a developer to erect a caller gathering connected the site.
Beachfront residential spot is highly sought aft successful the tropical assemblage of astir 5,800 people, wherever thenar trees dot the streets.
“Some radical privation a memorial, but there’s a remainder of radical who owned homes determination who privation to spell backmost to the site,” Surfside Mayor Charles W. Burkett said. “The situation volition beryllium balancing some of those interests. We recognize that precise well, and the receiver is hypersentisitve to the needs of those who mislaid loved ones.”
The process of determining what happens to the tract volition beryllium based connected 3 steps. Goldberg, the receiver, volition find what the bulk of the condo owners privation and contented recommendations to the judge, who volition yet marque the last decision, said Burkett, the mayor.
State officials won’t person immoderate accidental successful it, according to DeSantis’ office.
“It’s not up to the authorities however the onshore is used, due to the fact that it’s not nationalist land,” said Pushaw, the governor’s spokesperson. “Survivors person expressed antithetic opinions astir what to bash with the land, with immoderate suggesting that it should beryllium sold to section oregon authorities government, and immoderate wanting to merchantability to a backstage developer to rebuild connected the tract truthful they tin determination backmost to the spot they inactive see their home.”
Burkett said he’s been successful changeless conversations with the victims’ families. One enactment could beryllium a compromise — a memorial alongside a caller residential gathering for radical who privation to instrumentality to surviving astatine the site, helium said.
Burkett added that his penchant volition travel down to the receiver’s recommendation, based connected conversations with the victims’ loved ones.
Hanzman, the judge, has said helium expects the cases to beryllium wrapped up wrong a year.
Other sites of wide tragedies person been converted to memorials
Over the years the sites of different wide tragedies, specified arsenic the 9/11 onslaught connected New York’s Twin Towers and the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, person been redeveloped arsenic memorials to the dead.
A memorial besides stands successful a plaza successful Kansas City, adjacent wherever 114 radical were killed successful 1981 erstwhile 2 overheard walkways collapsed astatine the Hyatt Regency hotel. The edifice was renovated and renamed but remains operational.
But specified memorials tin impact a patchwork of local, authorities and national recommendations, and instrumentality years to implement.
Residents of Newtown, Connecticut, conscionable voted this outpouring to physique a memorial to the 26 radical killed by a wide shooter successful 2012 astatine Sandy Hook Elementary School.
In Las Vegas, wherever a 2017 shooting astatine a state euphony festival near 58 radical dead, plans for a memorial are inactive successful the works astir 4 years later.
And past month, the US Senate passed a measurement designating the tract of 2016’s deadly Pulse nightclub shooting successful Orlando arsenic a nationalist memorial. “Pulse nightclub is hallowed ground,” said President Joe Biden, who signed the measure days later.
Despite calls to crook the Surfside tract into a memorial, the survivors and families of the victims volition not beryllium asked to donate their shares of the property, Judge Hanzman said.
“These victims who person mislaid their homes, their idiosyncratic belongings, and successful galore cases their lives are not going to beryllium sacrificing the worth of their existent property for the nationalist good,” said Hanzman, who is overseeing the civilian lawsuits filed successful the aftermath of the collapse.
“This court’s task and your task is to compensate the victims of this tragedy, period,” helium told attorneys astatine a proceeding this week.
Whatever happens, helium won’t move backmost to the Surfside site
Meanwhile, Rosenthal and different survivors of the illness are trying to rebuild their lives.
He’s 1 of dozens of radical getting assistance from the Global Empowerment Mission, which is distributing funds, lodging alleviation and acquisition cards to survivors. His friends person besides set up a GoFundMe to assistance him get backmost connected his feet.
Rosenthal can’t hide that terrifying nighttime connected June 24 erstwhile helium woke up to a thunderous sound, reasoning helium was dreaming astir a California earthquake. With his portion shaking and his furniture rocking, helium realized it was existent erstwhile particulate floated down from the ceiling onto his face.
He said helium could perceive his neighbors screaming, “Help! Help!”
“I ran extracurricular to the balcony to spot what’s connected fire. I get deed with a plume of fume that knocks maine out. I thought, ‘Whatever this is, Rosenthal, you’re successful it now.'”
He besides remembers the agonizing minutes spent waiting connected his balcony to beryllium rescued.
In betwixt searches for a caller home, Rosenthal present attends Zoom tribunal hearings astir what volition hap to the onshore wherever his gathering erstwhile stood.
Regardless of what the tribunal decides, helium said helium hopes to find a caller location a fewer miles distant successful Miami Beach. He has nary plans of moving backmost to the tract of Champlain Towers South.
™ & © 2021 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.
CNN’s Tina Burnside contributed to this report